Le Martyr Imaginaire: Illness and Theatre in the Career of Gabriel Breynat, Bishop of the Mackenzie, 1901-1926
Issue: Vol 32 No. 2 (2013)
Journal: Religious Studies and Theology
Subject Areas: Religious Studies Buddhist Studies Islamic Studies Biblical Studies
Abstract:
Gabriel Breynat, Catholic bishop of the Mackenzie from 1901, claimed chronic illness due to the harsh task of evangelizing “the ends of the earth,” though he did not see the arctic coast for decades. Endless symptoms, combined with a grim “idea of north” among Vatican figures, fed the perception of his near-martyrdom to the cold. To play this to advantage, Breynat benefited from the emergence of neurasthenia as popular diagnosis, of rest as treatment, of intense medicalization of hydrotherapy in France, of the need for heroes in that country, and of Rome’s renewed interest in missions. Throughout, the role of suffering “bishop of the Pole” raised his status, brought support for good works, and made staff (nuns, priests, and brothers) work increasingly hard. While he sought health in far-off spas and wealthy widows’ homes, they struggled to effect his plans, including a hospital for Inuit to mark his reign’s silver anniversary. Western medicine, it turned out, seldom helped gain souls, yet its constructs can be key to grasping the white side of missions—both on site and at the heart of the church.
Author: Walter Vanast
References :
Anonymous, 1903. “Mgr. Breynat à Liège.” Missions O.M.I. 41: 143-6.
_________. 1922. “Notre Bibliothèque O.M.I.: Quelques Ouvrages Récents.” Missions O.M.I. 56: 449-450.
_________. 1923. “Les Missions du Pôle Nord à Rome.” Missions O.M.I. 57: 486-8.
_________. 1954a. “Peregrinare pro Christo. Le Dernier voyage de Monsieur Breynat: Son retour à la ‘maison du père.’” Numéro spécial du Courrier de Famille du Vicariat Apostolique du Mackenzie. Fort Smith, April, number 136. OASA.
_________. 1954b. A la pieuse mémoire de Son Excellence Mgr. Breynat, O.M.I. Pamphlet. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
Beard, George Miller. 1869. “Neurasthenia or Nervous Exhaustion,” Boston Medical and Surgical Journal, 3, 13:217-221.
_________. 1880. A Practical Treatise on Nervous Exhaustion. New York: William Wood.
_________. 1881. American Nervousness: Its Causes and Consequences. A Supplement to Nervous Exhaustion (Neurasthenia). Putnam and sons. E-book.
_________. 1884. Sexual Neurasthenia (Nervous Exhaustion): Its Hygiene, Causes, Symptoms and Treatment with a chapter on Diet for the Nervous. Ed. A. D. Rockwell. New York: E. B. Treat.
_________. 1888. A Practical Treatise on Nervous Exhaustion (Neurasthenia). Ed. A. D. Rockwell. New York: E. B. Treat.
Bender, Tamás, Zeki Karagűlle, Géza P. Bálint, Christoph Gutenbrunner, Péter V. Bálint, and Shaul Sukenik. 2005. “Hydrotherapy, Balneotherapy, and Spa Treatment in Pain Management.” Rheumatology International, 25:220-224.
Berton, Pierre. 2004. Prisoners of the North. Toronto: Doubleday.
Blackbourn, D. 2002. “Fashionable Spa Towns in Nineteenth-Century Europe.” In Water, Leisure and Culture: European historical perspectives, edited by S. C. Anderson, and B. H. Tabb, 9-22. Oxford: Berg.
Blackie, M. R. 2006. Rest Cures: The Narrative Life of a Medical Practice. PhD diss., University of Southern California. Web.
Blocq, Paul. 1891. “Neurasthenia.” Brain 14, 306-334.
Breynat, Gabriel. 1901. “Noel à la Mission des Sept Douleurs.” Missions O.M.I. 39: 141-145.
_________. 1902a. Circular Letter. December n.d. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1902b. “Adresse des évêques de la province ecclésiastique de Saint-Boniface au très révérend Père Général.” Missions O.M.I. 40: 233-5.
_________. 1905. Circular Letter. January 14. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1916. Circular Letter. March 13. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1920a. Letter to Clara Bourdeau . February 27. Breynat section, file Clara Bourdeau . Oblate Archives, Grandin Province, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1920b. Letter to Clara Bourdeau . April 4. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1920c. Letter to Van Rossum. May 21. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1920d. “Vicariat des Missions du Mackenzie.” Missions OMI 54: 286-293.
Breynat, Gabriel. 1924. Circular Letter. April 17. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1925. Circular Letter. April 12. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1933. Letter to Clara Bourdeau . May 7. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file Clara Bourdeau correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1945. Cinquante Ans Au Pays Des Neiges I: Chez Les Mangeurs De Caribou. Montreal: Fides.
_________. 1947. Cinquante Ans Au Pays Des Neiges: II. Voyageur Du Christ. Montreal: Fides.
_________. 1948. Cinquante Ans Au Pays Des Neiges III: L'Evêque Volant. Montreal: Fides.
_________. 1953. L’Évêque Volant. Paris: Amiot Dumont.
_________. 1955. The Flying Bishop: Fifty Years in the Canadian North, translated by A. Gordon Smith. London: Burns and Oates.
Briggs, Laura. 2000. “The Race of Hysteria: ‘Overcivilization’ and the ‘Savage Woman’ in Late Nineteeth-Century Obstretics and Gynecology.” American Quarterly 52 (2): 246-73.
Burns, Stanley B., and Jason L. Burns. 1997. “Photo-essay: Hydrotherapy.” Journal of Alternative and Complementary Medicine 3 (2): 105-7.
Choquette Robert. 1995. The Oblate Assault on Canada’s Northwest. Univ. of Ottawa Press.
Cluny, Roland. 1954. L’Évêque des Neiges. Paris: Centurion. Montréal: Apostolat de La Presse.
Di Maria P. 1922. Letter to Gabriel Breynat. June 8. Mackenzie Oblates, Breynat section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
Dimsdale, Joel, Neelom Sharma, and Michael Sharpe. 2011. “What do Physicians Think of Somatoform Disorders?” Psychosomatics 52:154-159.
Duchaussois, Pierre. 1921. Aux Glaces Polaires. Lyon: Œuvre Apostolique de Marie Immaculée. Re-issued in Paris, 1922.
_________. 1922. “Un Oblat aux Pieds du Pape.” Missions O.M.I. 56: 851-855.
_________. 1924. Apôtres Inconnus. Paris: SPES.
_________. 1926. Aux Glaces Polaires. New Edition. Paris: SPES.
_________. 1928. Femmes Héroïques: Les Sœurs Grises Canadiennes aux Glaces Polaires. Paris: SPES.
_________. 1937. Mid Snow and Ice: The Apostles of the Northwest, (tr. of Aux Glaces Polaires). Buffalo: Missionary Oblates of Mary Immaculate.
_________. 1959. Femmes Heroïques. Part I and II published separately, 94 p. each. Montreal: Rayonnement.
Duffy, Jacqueline. 1993. Review of Numbers, 1992a. History: Review of New Books. Taylor and Frances. Web.
Duport, Alphonse. 1920. Letter to Breynat. February 2. Mackenzie Oblates, Duport section, file correspondance. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1921. Letter to Gabriel Breynat. November 6, 1921. Mackenzie Oblates, Duport section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1922. Letter to Gabriel Breynat. March 15. Mackenzie Oblates, Duport section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1923. “Mission Saint-Joseph, Fort Resolution, N.W.T.” Missions O.M.I. 57: 212-217.
_________. 1924a. Letter to Gabriel Breynat. July 18. Mackenzie Oblates, Duport section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1924b. Letter to Gabriel Breynat. November 16. Mackenzie Oblates, Duport section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1924c. Circular letter. December 12. Mackenzie Oblates, Duport section, file correspondence. Oblate Archives (Grandin Province), St. Albert, Alberta.
Fors, E. A., T. C. Stiles, and P.C. Borchgrevink. 2012. “Somatoform Disorders.” In Encyclopedia of Human Behavior, 2nd ed., 512-518. http://www.sciencedirect.com/science/article/pii/B9780123750006003402
Freud, S. 1895. “On the Grounds for Detaching a Particular Syndrome from Neurasthenia under the Description ‘Anxiety Neurosis.’” Reprinted (1953-74) in the Standard Edition of the Complete Works of Sigmund Freud, volume 3, translated and edited by J. Strachey, 90-115.
Gelfand, Toby. 2000. “Neurologist or Psychiatrist? The Public and Private Domains of Jean-Martin Charcot.” Journal of the History of the Behavioral Sciences 36:3, 215-229.
Gordon, Bertram M. 2012. “Reinventions of a Spa Town: the Unique Case of Vichy.” Journal of Tourism History 4:1, 35-55.
Grace, Sherill E. 2001. Canada and the Idea of North. McGill Queen’s University Press.
Grace, Sherrill E., Eve D’Aeth, and Lisa Chalikoff eds. 1999. Staging the North: Twelve Canadian Plays. Toronto: Playwrights Canada.
Grouard, Émile. 1922. Souvenirs de mes Soixante Ans d'Apostolat dans l'Athabasca-Mackenzie. Oeuvre Apostolique de Marie Immaculée, Lyon.
Haustgen, T. 2011. “Les états nerveux dans l’histoire de la médecine. Deuxième partie: de la neurasthénie au trouble anxiété généralisée. ” Psychiatr. Sci. Hum. Neurosci. 9:41-54
Jackson, Ralph. 1990. “Waters and Spas in the Classical World.” Medical History. Supplement 10, 1-13.
Kroenke, Kurt, Michael Sharpe, and Richard Sykes. 2007. “Revising the Classification of Somatoform Disorders: Key Questions and Preliminary Recommendations.” Psychosomatics 48, 4: 277-285.
Levasseur, Donat. O.M.I. 1995. Les Oblats de Marie Immaculée dans l’Ouest et le Nord du Canada, 1845-1967. Edmonton: Univ. of Alberta Press and Western Canadian Publishers.
Levenson, James. 2011. “The Somatoform Disorders: 6 Characters in Search of an Author.” Psychiatric Clinics of North America 34: 515-524.
McCarthy, Martha. 1995. From the Great River to the Ends of the Earth. Edmonton: University of Alberta Press.
Micale, Mark S. 1990. “Charcot and the Idea of Hysteria in the Male: Gender, Mental Science, and Medical Diagnosis in Late Nineteenth Century France.” Medical History 34, 363-411.
Molière (Jean-Baptiste Poquelin). 1673. Le Malade Imaginaire. http://www.inlibroveritas.net/lire/oeuvre377.html
Naraindas, Harish, and Christiana Bastos. 2011. “Healing Holidays? Itinerant Patients, Therapeutic Locales and the Quest for Health.” Anthropology and Medicine 18:1, 1-6. Web.
Numbers, Ronald L. 1992. Prophetess of Health: Ellen G. White and the Origins of Seventh-Day Adventist Health Reform. 2nd ed. Univ. of Tennessee Press.
Numbers, Ronald L., and Janet Numbers. 2008. “Afterword: Ellen White on the Mind and the Mind of Ellen White.” In Ronald L. Numbers, Prophetess of Health: A Study of Ellen C. White, 3rd Edition, 267-290. Grand Rapids: Wm. Eerdmans.
Pert, C. B., H. E. Dreher, and M. R. Ruff. 1998. “The Psychosomatic Network: Foundations of Body-Mind Medicine.” Alternative Therapies in Health and Medicine 4 (4):30-41.
Pickering, George. 1974. Creative Malady: Illness in the Lives and Minds of Charles Darwin, Florence Nightingale, Mary Baker Eddy, Sigmund Freud, Marcel Proust, Elizabeth Barrett Browning. New York: Oxford Univ. Press.
Pius XI. 1926. Rerum Ecclesiae. Encyclical. Vatican. Web.
Providence Nuns (PN). 1903. Chroniques. October 6. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1905. Chroniques. July 1. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1907. Chroniques. February 19-21. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1910. Chroniques. March 8 and 21. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1913a. Chroniques. August 16-22. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1913b. Chroniques. October 19. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1913c. Chroniques. December 15. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1914a. Chroniques. January 22-25. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1914b. Chroniques. February 12, 14-15, 22 and 24. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1915a. Chroniques. June 27. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1915b. Chroniques. August 2-10. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1916a. Chroniques. February 24. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1916b. Chroniques. June 26. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1916c. Chroniques. August 11. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1917a. Chroniques. January 31. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1917b. Chroniques. March 5. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1921a. Chroniques. June 4. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1921b. Chroniques. July 3. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1922a. Chroniques. June 29. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1922b. Chroniques. August 11. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1923a. Chroniques. February 6. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1923b. Chroniques. March 24 and 30. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1923c. Chroniques. April 1. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
Resolution Nuns (RN). Chroniques. March 7, 1916. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. July 18, 1920. Chroniques. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. June 22 and 26, 1924. Chroniques. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. March 24, 1925. Chroniques. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. June 4, 1926a. Chroniques. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. June 8, 1926b. Chroniques. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. June 9, 1926c. Chroniques. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. July 10, 1926d. Chroniques. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
Resolution Priests (RP). 1903. Codex Historicus. June 8. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1911. Codex Historicus. October 8-14 and 18. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1912a. Codex Historicus. March 3. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1912b. Codex Historicus. March 9, 17, 20, 22 and 24. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1912c. Codex Historicus. October 31. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1912d. Codex Historicus. April 5 and 25. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1913. Codex Historicus. June 12. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1914a. Codex Historicus. March 13. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1914b. Codex Historicus. July 7. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1915. Codex Historicus. August 9, 19, and 25. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1916a. Codex Historicus. September 23 and 29. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1916b. Codex Historicus. December 13-14. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1917a. Codex Historicus. January 14 and 26. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1917b. Codex Historicus. March 18, 20, 27 and 30. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1917c. Codex Historicus. May 03, 05-06 and 14. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1920a. Codex Historicus. March 5. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1920b. Codex Historicus. June 18. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1920c. Codex Historicus. July 18. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1921a. Codex Historicus. February 5. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1921b. Codex Historicus. April 13. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1921c. Codex Historicus. July 3. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1921d. Codex Historicus. October 24. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1922a. Codex Historicus. March 22. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1922b. Codex Historicus. June 6. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1922c. Codex Historicus. August 19 and 30. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1923a. Codex Historicus. January 11. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1923b. Codex Historicus. April 7-9 and 27. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1923c. Codex Historicus. May 28. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1924. Codex Historicus. June 8. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1925a. Codex Historicus. March 24. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1925b. Codex Historicus. March 29. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1925c. Codex Historicus. June 11 and 31. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1925d. Codex Historicus. December 31. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1926a. Codex Historicus. March 19, 24. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1926b. Codex Historicus. April 6. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1926c. Codex Historicus. May 13. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1926d. Codex Historicus. June 2 and 8. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1926e. Codex Historicus. June 9. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
_________. 1926f. Codex Historicus. July 10. Oblate Archives, St. Albert, Alberta.
Rymer, J. 1912. “Fête de Noel Passée avec Mgr. Breynat, o.m.i. au Pays des Indiens dans l'Extrême-Nord,” Petites Annales 1: 29-34.
Sanneh, Lamin. 1990. “Mission and the Modern Imperative—Retrospect and Prospect: charting a course.” In Earthen Vessels, American Evangelicals and Foreign Missions, 1880-1980. edited by A. Carpenter and Wilbur R. Schenk. 301-316. Grand Rapids, William B. Eerdmans.
Shorter, Edward. 2008. From Paralysis to Fatigue: A History of Psychosomatic Illness in the Modern Era. Simon and Shuster. (First edition 1992. New York: Free Press).
Simoni, Father. 1902. “Sacrée de Mgr Breynat.” Missions O.M.I. 40: 227-232.
Simpson Nuns (SN). Chroniques. July 12, 1921a. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1921b. Chroniques. September 6. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1922a. Chroniques. July 19 and 23. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
_________. 1922b. August 7 and 9. Chroniques. Grey Nun Archives, Edmonton, Alberta.
Stefansson, Vilhjalmur. 1922. The Friendly Arctic, the Story of Five Years in the Polar Regions. New York: MacMillan.
Taylor, Ruth E. 2001. “The Death of Neurasthenia and its Psychological Reincarnation.” Brit. J. of Psychiatry, 179, 550-557.
Vanast, Walter. 1992. “Compassion, Cost and Competition. Factors in the Evolution of Oblate Health Care Provision in the Canadian North.” Western Oblate Studies 2/ Etudes Oblates de l'Ouest 2. Occasional Paper No. 1, Centre for the Study of North American Religion, 179-195. Lewiston, NY: Edwin Mellon.
_________. 1996. “Arctic Bodies, Frontier Souls: Missionaries and Medical Care in the Canadian North, 1896-1926.” PhD diss., University of Wisconsin, Madison.
van Tubergen, A., and S. van der Linden. 2002 “A Brief History of Spa Therapy.” Ann Rheum. Dis. 61:273-275.
van Tubergen, A., A. Boonen, R. Landewe et al. 2002. “Cost Effectiveness of Combined Spa-Exercise Therapy in Ankylosing Spondylitis: A Randomized Controlled Trial.” Arthritis Rheum. 47:459-467.
Verounden, Nick W., and Frans J. Meijman. 2010 “Water, Health and The Body: The Tide, Undercurrent and Surge of Meanings.” Water Hist. 2: 19-33.
Wessely, Simon. 1994. “Neurasthenia and Chronic Fatigue: Theory and Practice in Britain and America.” Transcultural Psychiatry 31, 2:173-209.
Young, Theron Kue-Hing. 1973. “A Conflict of Professions: The Medical Missionary in China, 1835-1890.” Bulletin of the History of Medicine 47: 250-272.
Zaslow, Morris. 1988. The Northward Expansion of Canada, 1914-1967. Toronto: McClelland and Stewart.